$ 689,000

51181 Broadway Street, Malahide

A home with a story unlike any other. Originally a church and later a community centre, this remarkable Springfield property has been thoughtfully transformed into a spacious residence while preserving the soaring ceilings, character and history that make it so special. The church was relocated to Springfield in 1871 and has since been extensively updated for modern living. Set on an oversized residential lot, the property features a newer two-tiered deck and saltwater pool, creating an incredible space for entertaining and enjoying the warmer months. Inside, the expansive main level offers impressive ceiling heights, a spacious kitchen and two bedrooms, while the second level provides additional flexible living space, secondary access and room to explore future possibilities, including space for an additional kitchen. This is far more than a cosmetic renovation, with extensive improvements including siding, insulation, windows, kitchen, electrical, plumbing, ceilings, floors, walls, bathrooms, HVAC and ductwork, along with a new roof in 2026, Bosch dishwasher in 2026, Trane furnace and central air in 2021, windows in 2019 and a newer sewage injection pump. Pieces of the property's past remain woven into the home today, including a rear storage area once used as the church stable, where horses were tied before services. Over the years, this building has been a church, community centre, gathering place filled with music and celebrations, and ultimately a labour of love transformed into a truly unique home. Recently surveyed and zoned residential, this one-of-a-kind property offers history, character, space and the opportunity for its next owner to write the next chapter. (id:1945)
Powered by REALTOR.ca
This listing content provided by REALTOR.ca has been licensed by REALTOR®
members of The Canadian Real Estate Association

Property details for 51181 Broadway Street, Malahide

Type
Residential
Style
Raised bungalow
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
3
Lot Size
70 x 137.7 FT
Stories
1
Basement
Finished, Separate entrance, N/A, N/A
Parking
No Garage
Heating
Forced air, Natural gas
Cooling
Central air conditioning
Exterior
Vinyl siding
Ownership
Freehold
Annual Taxes
$3,486

Nearby Listings Stat

Estimated price and comparable properties near 51181 Broadway Street

Active Listings
1
Min Price
$689,000
Max Price
$689,000
Avg Price
$689,000
Days on Market
60
days
Sold Listings
0
Min Sold Price
$N/A
Max Sold Price
$N/A
Avg Sold Price
$N/A
Days until Sold
N/A
days

Price History

Listed
August 24, 2026
by EXP REALTY
Current Price
$689,000
-2.9% from last change
Type
Residential
For Sale
Price Changes
2
Date Price Change
Current $689,000 $20,900 (-2.9%)
Sep 29, 2026 $709,900 +$134,900 (+23.5%)
Aug 24, 2026 $575,000 Listed

Contact Agent Get in touch about 51181 Broadway Street, Malahide

RICHARD CARVELL
RICHARD CARVELL
EXP REALTY

Similar Homes near 51181 Broadway Street, Malahide, ON N0L2J0

Comparison of 51181 Broadway Street, Malahide, ON with Nearby Homes