$ 355,000

Charming 2-Storey with Porch & Yard in Dunnville

Property details for 305 North Cayuga Street W, Dunnville

Type
Residential
Style
Other
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
2
Living Area
1,526 square feet
Stories
1.5
Basement
Unfinished, Crawl space
Heating
Hot water radiator heat, Space Heater, Natural gas
Cooling
None
Exterior
Vinyl siding
Ownership
Freehold
Annual Taxes
$2,049

This place sits in quiet, older Dunnville, close to the Grand River and a quick drive to Rock Point Provincial Park for beach days. The house itself is a 1.5-storey, 1526 sq ft layout from 1895 with three beds and two full baths. It's not fancy, but it's honest. The main floor has a bedroom (currently used as a den), a full 3pc bath, and a laundry setup, so you could do single-level living if you wanted. The eat-in kitchen is huge, with original green cabinets and a red diner table that'll make you feel like you're in a 1950s time warp. There's also a separate dining room and a living room that could use some fresh paint. Upstairs, you'll find two more bedrooms plus another 3pc bath, though the primary has a sloped ceiling and one room shows peeling wallpaper. The lot is 40 feet wide, and the fully fenced backyard is a generous open green space with a storage shed and space for your truck. A wrap-around porch is the real highlight, perfect for coffee and watching the street go by. Price sits at $355,000, which is well under the nearby median of $419,900, making it one of the more affordable options in the area. It needs updating, and there's no AC (you'll rely on those radiators and a space heater in winter), but the bones are solid with vinyl siding and a newer-looking roof. If you're up for a project, this has potential, and it's a solid investment at this price.

About 305 North Cayuga Street W, Dunnville — Property Score

72
Well Priced Spacious Great Location
Score: 72/100
Value
83
Priced 40.8% below area median of $599,900 based on 21 comparable properties nearby 100
$233/sqft - 48.6% below the $453/sqft area median 100
Stable pricing - no price changes since original listing date 50
Size
80
1,526 sqft - 46% more space than similarly priced homes (1,048 sqft median) 97
3 bedrooms - 1 more than similarly priced 2-bedroom homes nearby 72
2 bathrooms - 1 more than similarly priced properties nearby 72
Location
76
$50K median household income - below the Canadian average of $70K 55
56% of residents hold postsecondary credentials - an above-average education level 67
75% homeownership rate - indicating a stable, owner-occupied community 83
63% of residents commute under 30 minutes - excellent commuter accessibility 80
2,559/km² population density - a well-balanced suburban area 96
Market
73
Just listed - area average is 34 days on market 100
+5.9% median price change over 1 month - rising prices in the area 80
23 months of housing supply - 46 active listings with 2 sold last month (buyer's market) 40
Features
57
2-car parking - area average is 6.3 spots 80
Unfinished, Crawl space basement - adds valuable living space 85
Hot water radiator heat, Space Heater, Natural gas 60
None 30
Built in 1895 (131 years old) - established home with character, older than the area average (1958) 35
No premium extras like pool, waterfront, or view 50
Investment
72
0.56% effective tax rate ($1,985/yr) - very low tax burden 83
25% renter population - primarily owner-occupied area 60
Quality
58
Functional layout with separate dining and living rooms 70
Vinyl siding exterior, standard interior materials 60
Potential for cosmetic updates throughout the home 50
Heating system present, no central cooling mentioned 50
Condition
75
Vinyl siding appears well-maintained, good condition roof 75
Expansive rear yard with storage shed, mature trees 70
Charming wrap-around porch and inviting front entrance 80
Listing
84
Listing description quality 75
33 photos provided - below the area average of 44 photos 92
6 of 7 key property details provided (86%) - comprehensive listing with excellent detail 86

This 3-bed, 2-bath Dunnville home offers excellent value at $355,000, significantly below the area median of $599,900. The 1526 sqft property boasts charming features like a wrap-around porch and a large backyard, presenting a fantastic opportunity for buyers looking to customize their living space.

* This property score is an approximate estimate based on publicly available data, nearby comparable listings, and automated analysis. Scores are for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as professional appraisals or investment advice. Actual property values may vary. We recommend consulting a licensed real estate professional for accurate assessments.

Full Listing Description

All Property Details

Neighbourhood Census Data

Haldimand County, Ontario

Population
445
Median Age
42.7
Median Income
$26,816
Dwelling Value
$200,387

Housing Tenure

Owners 75%
Renters 25%

Age Distribution

Dwelling Types

Commute Mode

Education Level

Housing Age

Commute Duration

Avg Household Size: 2.3
Pop. Density: 2,558.9/km²
Avg Shelter Cost: $822/mo
Owners with Mortgage: 56.7%
Owners Spending 30%+: 23.3%
Tenants Spending 30%+: 40%
English only: 98.9%
English and French: 1.1%
Median Household Income: $49,664
Median Employment Income: $25,920

Price History

Contact Agent Get in touch about 305 North Cayuga Street W, Dunnville

Isaac Phillips
Isaac Phillips
Royal LePage State Realty Inc.

Photo Gallery - 305 North Cayuga Street W, Dunnville

Exterior

A traditional two-story house with white vinyl siding and a covered front porch is shown on a sunny day with a green lawn and mature trees.

Mixed covered front porch with railing two-story house vinyl siding

A white vinyl-sided house with a covered front porch, lawn, and paved walkway.

Mixed covered front porch wood siding lawn

A white clapboard house with a covered front porch and dormer window sits on a green lawn, bordered by trees and a paved street.

Mixed covered porch white vinyl siding wood railings

A white, two-story house with a covered front porch and wood railings sits on a grassy lawn with mature trees and a shed.

Mixed covered front porch white siding wood railings

A white-sided house with a covered front porch and a large green lawn is visible on a sunny day with mature trees.

Original covered front porch white siding green lawn

A covered front porch with two chairs and a small table overlooks a grassy yard with a house in the background.

Original porch two metal chairs small side table

Living Room

A vintage living room with floral furniture and a carpet, featuring a screen door leading outside.

Original floral sofa armchair curtains

A living room with a floral sofa, display cabinet, and view into a bathroom and another room with a ceiling fan.

Original floral sofa glass display cabinet ceiling fan

A carpeted room with a window, floor lamp, and a heater.

Dated window curtains floor lamp

Kitchen

A vintage kitchen features green cabinetry, a diner-style table with chairs, wood paneled walls, and a white gas stove.

Original white gas stove green cabinetry red and white diner table

A dated kitchen featuring a vintage stove, retro dining set, green cabinetry, and wood paneled walls.

Dated vintage stove retro dining set green cabinetry

A vintage kitchen features green cabinetry, a white refrigerator, and a red and chrome dining set in front of a window.

Original white refrigerator green cabinetry red and chrome kitchen table

Other

This is a cluttered shed with a round table, storage boxes, and windows overlooking a grassy yard.

Dated round table storage boxes watering can

Bedrooms

This bedroom features a sloped ceiling, peeling wallpaper on one wall, and worn hardwood floors. A wooden bench sits in the center of the room, and a single window is visible on the far wall.

Dated sloped ceiling attic access single window

Backyard

A spacious backyard with a large green lawn, mature trees, and a white house with a driveway.

Original large green lawn mature trees chain-link fence